Skip to Content
Newsletter

How Can I Ask for No Gifts to Reduce My Waste This Holiday Season?

And is eating some fish better for the environment than others?

4:56 PM EST on November 19, 2026

Hi there, and welcome back to the Q&A edition of one5c! If you’ve got your own Q to be A’d, send it to editors@one5c.com.

What’s on your minds:

> The no-gift guide
> Eating fish sustainably

We only have two today, since we dive deep into the topics. Let’s get into it.

* * * * *

I don’t need more things this holiday season. How can I ask for no gifts to reduce my waste in a way that people will actually listen? —Chrissy

It’s that time of year when family and friends are starting to ask for your winter holiday wish list. But in a world where we have too much stuff to begin with, gifts can be an especially touchy subject. More than half of Americans unwrapped a present they didn’t want in 2024, adding up to roughly $10 billion worth of stuff that got returned, is sitting somewhere collecting dust, or, worse, is already burping methane in a landfill. 

The best answer for a planet-minded holiday gift-receiver is to simply forgo presents. This might seem as simple as writing “no gifts, please” on an invitation, but getting your loved ones to follow suit can be tricky.

While the phrase “no gifts, please” is pretty direct, it often prompts confusion and even fear among potential gift-givers. “We express social closeness and care for one another through gift exchange,” says Ayelet Fishbach, a professor of behavioral science and marketing at the University of Chicago. “For some, there are no good substitutes—expressing emotions directly may feel awkward.” It can be hard for them to cut off this form of communication, she adds; not gifting can feel like not saying how they feel. 

One way to get the point across effectively is turning a “no” into a “yes,” a fliparoo that can still preserve the gifter’s agency. Instead of saying “no” to being spoiled by loved ones every now and again, you can say “yes” to alternative treats that aren’t just another candle or hoodie that might end up returned, donated, or regifted. There are endless ways to make this happen—and create opportunities for new fond memories along the way. Here’s a few of my favorites… 

Embrace the Swap. Whether it’s clothes, toys, home decor, or gadgets, the swap party works overtime. It can delight recipients with a new-to-them item, offer attendees an opportunity to declutter, and help promote circularity all while saving some cash. If you’re hosting, ask attendees to bring gently used items that align with your theme, be it a sweater swap, book swap, kitchen gadget swap, or beyond. And ask that items come unwrapped or in newspaper or other scrap paper to cut out that waste, too. This is a great alternative to a White Elephant or Secret Santa party.

Pick a Cause. Some folks, no matter how hard you beg, will be compelled to spend money on you. So let them. Start associating with a cause that’s important to you, and let persistent gifters know that you’d like a donation in your name. (You can peruse options that fit your interests on Charity Navigator, or opt for an overarching planet-promoting org like the World Resources Institute, the Sierra Club Foundation, and the Environmental Defense Fund.)   

You can send out donation links or add them to a party invite, or just regularly reinforce to folks that you’re cutting waste and plan to make a cause your preferred method of accepting presents. This is a great way to funnel their well-meaning gift-giving energy into something that goes toward bettering the planet, rather than ravaging it. 

Choose an Edible or Drinkable Gift. Great gifts are ones that don’t go to waste, so consider requesting food or drink. Some go-tos include sustainable chocolates, coffee, fruit baskets, movie-watching snack bundles, hot sauces, olive oil and balsamic vinegar, booze, baked goods, and coffee. Giving these outright is great; so is a three-month subscription for delivery of these special products.

Ask for Time, Not things. There’s a host of research that suggests spending time together makes us happier than spending money on one another. If there’s something you’d want a friend or family member to teach you, outright ask them. Try something like, “Hey, instead of a holiday present this year, would you spend the day teaching me how to make your tiramisu?” Or buy tickets to see their favorite band in concert or show coming to town.

* * * * *

I’m a pescatarian. Is eating some fish better for the environment than others? And is wild-caught or farmed fish more sustainable? —Jane

If you’re going to consume animal protein—and you’re not going to hunt it yourself—fish is a good way to go. The caveat here is that you need to pick the right fish, harvested the right way, from the right place.

“We actually have three different standards for sustainability,” says Erin Hudson, Seafood Watch program director at the Monterey Bay Aquarium. “We have a standard for wild-caught fisheries; we have a standard for aquaculture; and we have a standard for salmonid species.” The organization weighs what gear is used to catch the wild fish, how farmed ones are fed, how the surrounding ecosystems are affected by the harvesting, and more. 

You might want to bookmark seafoodwatch.org. The scientists and staffers there spend their days crunching data and reports in order to qualify the impact of any sea creature you could imagine eating. They package that information in a series of guides that are available for anyone to use. Seafood Watch’s recommendations tool is great for at-the-counter (or table) decisions, and the seasonally updated regional guides are fast-glance gold for keeping the better options at the front of your mind.

Farmed Versus Wild-Caught Fish

These are terrific resources, but they do leave out one major thing: carbon emissions. According to Hudson, the complex web of global trade, among other considerations, makes it incredibly difficult for them to calculate the emissions accrued by your particular piece of fish. It may have been hand-caught by an angler on the shores of an Elysian river, but if that water was halfway around the world and that filet was shipped overnight to wherever you’re eating it, you might have been better off going for the product of a nearby inland salmon farm. 

Fish farms, of course, have their own challenges. In an inland operation, you need to power all manner of systems, including the pumps, filters, and aerators that keep the fish healthy. That’s a lot of electricity.

Open-net pens—which are giant, cordoned-off operations sited in the sea—aren’t plugged into the local electric grid in the same way, but they face other environmental issues. “There are severe pollution problems, often caused by antibiotic use, but also simply by the fact that all the waste goes into the ocean,” says Boris Worm, professor of marine biology at Dalhousie University. “It’s like having a pig farm that pipes its effluent directly into the ocean.”

Just like a pig farm, the animals need more food than they can scavenge themselves, which adds to the inefficiency. “The feed conversion ratio is often less than one-to-one for farmed fish,” says Worm, “so you are actually reducing the total amount of food by feeding them something that could be consumed in the first place.”

There may be fish farms powered by renewable energy with no harmful waste entering the ecosystem and conversion ratios that make the added inputs totally worth it, but there’s no easy way to find them. So, it’s generally best to avoid farmed fish.

Choosing Between Different Types of Fish

Not every local, wild-caught fish is fair game. “Some forms of fishing, like trawling or dredging, tend to be carbon-intensive,” says Worm. “And some fisheries, such as lobster here in Nova Scotia, are sustainable from a stock perspective—they’re not overfished—but they have a huge carbon footprint because it’s a lot of small boats chasing fairly small animals with not a lot of food in them.” In other words, wild-caught lobsters, shrimp, and crab are some of the worst wild-caught options based on emissions.

That said, there’s not a consistent good option. “You get stuck playing this old tape in your head, that X seafood is all good or all bad, but conditions change,” says Hudson. “We release new recommendations every month.” 

Worm agrees that “the devil is very often in the detail,” but he also has solid advice you can apply to any animal you might consider eating. “Just like on land, species lower on the food chain tend to have a lower carbon footprint,” he says. In the ocean, that’s “fish such as herring, mackerel, sardines, and anchovies.” Large predator species like tuna and swordfish, meanwhile, are the lions and tigers of the sea.

That said, one pretty consistently eco-friendly option is farmed mollusks: oysters, mussels, and clams. These are about the best animals you can eat—period. “They filter food out of water, so they live without external inputs, improving water quality in the process,” says Worm. “They also build shells, and those shells are made from calcium carbonate. That locks up large amounts of carbon, removing it from the environment.”

This might seem like a lot to keep in your head when you’re just trying to score dinner, but Hudson sums up what you should find out before you put anything in your reusable shopping bag (or belly): “You need to know what kind of fish it is, where’s it from, and how it was caught or farmed.” Between Google Maps and Seafood Watch’s recommendation tool, you can make an educated decision about what impact your catch of the day will have on the future of the planet.

How do you find out that info? You have to ask questions.

Lead image credit: nicoletaionescu / Adobe Stock

Related Stories

How I Cut Paper Towels Out of My Life

And how to recycle pet food cans

November 18, 2026

A Garbageman on What You’re Throwing Away That You Shouldn’t

And the best egg substitutes for plant-based cooking

November 16, 2026

Do “Ugly” Produce Rescue Services Really Cut Down on Food Waste?

And the quest for a sustainable broom

November 12, 2026

The Most Eco-friendly Way to Pick Up Dog 💩

And 4 home energy upgrades to make before winter

November 11, 2026

How to Recycle the Election Signs in Your Yard

And what the ‘blue wave’ means for U.S. climate policy

November 9, 2026